Doctor Who Project - "The Girl in the Fireplace"

Ok, going to try something different for this review, you may have noticed that my last few reviews have been a little different in format from the ones that proceeded them and I guess it's my way of being creative and finding a way of keeping the idea fresh (especially when you've got 50+ episodes to review). It's a mighty task but an enjoyable one (although not looking forward to the DVD that contains "Fear Her" and "Love and Monsters" on the same disc. Anyway back to the task in hand. I think for this review I am going to write it live as I'm watching the story, no edits (apart from grammatical ones) so what you'll probably get is unadulterated gibberish! I guess in a way it's kinda like a DVD commentary only in text format!  Nevertheless here we go.

Ooh space, oh nevermind it's a big state home. Madame de Pompadour, quite fancy her. Mistress? Queen? Shouting The Doctor's name into a fireplace, all the mystery!

Opening titles, STEVEN MOFFAT! Yay. Ok at this stage in time he's only written one Doctor Who story albeit one of the best so far.

lol Had to laugh at Mickey's first line, "Yes, spaceship on my first go". Funny that, Rose got one too. Well a space station at least.

Ooh fireplace on a spaceship and a girl on the other side of it.

TARDIS translation, bit of Doctor Who folk law thrown in there and a joke at Mickey's expense.

The Doctor finally meets the girl in person and it's weeks in her future, altogether now "wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey". Scary monster time and under the bed too! Moffat is going to terrify a generation! Once again he's made everyday things scary, in this case a ticking clock.

Fire extenguisher that looks like a gun. Another Doctor uses a gun but doesn't joke (see "Dalek" from the 1st series eg hairdryer that looks like a big gun).

Quite like Mickey's tshirt in this episode, old school Nintendo NES joypad. Ok that was a bit random.

Wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey time again, Reinette is now fully grown. Ding dong.

Ah Reinette has known The Doctor since she was 7 years old and it's a Steven Moffat story too. Hmm where have I seen this before? Amy Pond anyone? I can see why people say the Amy Pond story arc is a more fleshed out tale of  "The Girl in the Fireplace".

Human body parts hard-wired into the spaceship, this shit got serious!

Wonder what the horse is called? Susan (series 7 joke)?!

Repair droid 7? Doesn't sound very threatening. The repetition of "we did not have the parts" sounds very similar to the "we are in a car" line (by K9) in the previous story. Why 18th century France indeed? Nice question by Rose, "why her?".

Haha the horse is called Arthur and he's allowed to keep the horse because Rose is allowed to keep Mickey.

I like how Mickey is referring to women in The Doctor's past. Jealous boyfriend, funny that he seemed to have come to terms with it in the last story although he's obviously trying to point out to Rose that he's (The Doctor) not perfect.

Nice little memory scene there with Reinette and The Doctor. Not sure about the whole 'Doctor Who?' line again. Another thing that Moffat seems to have revisited recently.

Haha The Doctor is pissed (drunk for all you non UK readers)! Or appears to be at least. "Always take a banana to a party", good advice! And The Doctor has figured it all out, the repair droids are after Reinette's brain to install into the spaceship and it has to be the same age as the ship, that's why she's not compatible yet.

Funny how the droids are all retro with the clockwork action but they can beam right out of the ship into an exact period of time in 18th century France. Convenient!

Interesting analysis, The Doctor and the monsters, can't have one without the other.

Madame de Pomadour is very composed in what may essentially be her last moments. Love how she's building up The Doctor, the nightmare returned and here he comes on horseback. Didn't David Tennant do that in Casanova?

How is The Doctor going to get back? Well pointed out Mickey. Rose on the overhand is devastated. Ooh nice pun there by the good Doctor, "I'm not winding you up". Do bad guys stop when they have no purpose? I suppose villains like the Cybermen and the Daleks can never stop as their purpose is to make others like them and destroy anything unlike them respectively.

The Doctor, the 'lonely angel' stuck on the slow path (love Moffat's way with words). He clearly knew there was no way back, do you think he did it out of love for Reinette (there is a lot of suggestion in this story after all that The Doctor could fall/is in love with her) or was he just being entirely selfless. Conveniently though the original fireplace has been transported brick by brick to this palace and it's The Doctor's way back to the TARDIS.

Once again The Doctor meets a young lady he wants to take onboard the TARDIS and she winds up dying (see Lynda with a Y). This time he just misses her, her coffin being taken to Paris to be buried.

Wonder what Reinette said to The Doctor in her letter? Hope it's explained as I can't remember it at all.

The Doctor is clearly upset, I'm guessing he could've loved her. Never did buy the whole he loved Rose thing but Madame de Pompadour definitely.

Just heard what she said in the letter, so sad and the light going out in the fireplace too very fitting.

And with the last shots of the episode we see a portrait of Reinette and the name of the ship clearing any confusion as to why they (clockwork repair droids) needed her at all.

And that's it my first (and possibly last! lol) live commentary review. Hope anyone reading this enjoyed it and didn't just read it as mindless drivel. Such a great episode and at this stage that's two great stories in two attempts from Steven Moffat. Someone should give him the show runner job. ;)

Next up the Cyberman 2 parter! Exciting times.

Doctor Who Project "School Reunion"

The return of Sarah-Jayne Smith and K9 (mk3) in Russell T Davies' biggest nod to the classic series. You have to love how RTD melds the new and old with direct comparisons throughout the episode from Rose and Sarah-Jayne to Mickey and K9 (I also love Mickey's realisation that he's the tin dog!). Then there's that great conversation between Sarah-Jayne and Rose about what it's like to travel with the Doctor (including pointing out his idiosyncrasies) and of course Sarah-Jayne and The Doctor's catch up in which she finally gets the chance to confront him about leaving her in Aberdeen and not coming back for her. In fact that's what is the heart of this story, reminiscing, exploring the relationship The Doctor has with his companions and of course what happens to the companions when they step out of the TARDIS for the last time. The monsters in this week even take a back seat to the characters in what can be described as RTD's love letter to Sarah-Jayne Smith.

Also worthy of note is the schoolboy fantasy played out in this episode ie the awkward kid who has a hand in saving the day being lauded by his school mates after the school blows up. There's also loads of little jokes like Rose believing the teachers sleep at school (and being proved right), the teachers and dinner ladies being monsters.

Oh and after sacrificing himself K9 returns at the end, a replacement from The Doctor and a nod to classic Who again ('The Invasion of Time' - I'm sure there's other instances but only really know of this one). I'm sure this was done deliberately, setting both Sarah-Jayne and K9 for their own spinoff shows. As well as providing a happy ending of course.

All in all another great story. The monsters are pretty forgettable, they could be any monster in fact and Anthony Stewart Head's character even alludes to the fact that they (the Krillitines) adopt new features everytime they conquer a race. Not that any of this matters as it's all about the TARDIS crew new and old coming together and talking about what it's like to travel with The Doctor (and to suddenly stop doing so - foreshadowing?!!).

Brilliant episode, easily one of the best of the series and a modern classic. Love it.

Doctor Who Project - "Tooth and Claw"

Unlike most of the episodes I've re-watched so far I think I actually like  "Tooth and Claw" a little less the second time around. It just seems a bit dull, the "we are not amused" joke comes across as forced and the wolf in Rose line was last series.

On the plus side: David Tennant's natural (Scottish) accent, the psychic paper is back, the wolf looks good and the BBC One ident inspired monks in red outfits intro. Kinda reminiscent of this:

There's also more references to Torchwood, far more blatant in this episode what with the Torchwood Estate being the backdrop for the story and the creation of the Torchwood Institute.

Overall, pretty meh. It was ok but not spectacular. Guess kids will find it scary.

Next the return of one of The Doctor's  greatest companions Sarah-Jayne Smith.

Spot the difference!

Doctor Who Project - "New Earth"

The first thing I noticed about this episode is that it's the first story since the show's return to be set on another planet (OK we came pretty close with the Platform 1 and Satellite 5/the Gamestation but they were in orbit around Earth). Seems odd that I've only just picked up on that but maybe the first series was set predominately on Earth deliberately. OK not like a Pertwee banishment to Earth but more of a BBC budget restriction and the success of that first series allowed them a bigger chunk and the freedom to create new worlds?

Interesting point over. This episode is probably most memorable for the return of Cassandra and The Face of Boe from "The End of the World". Not sure why either warrants a return to be honest.

I guess "New Earth" is Russell T Davies commenting on colonialism (the human race expanding into the stars and naming new places after old places back home ie how many places in the US are named after towns and cities from the UK, Ireland etc? Even New York's name comes from York so what better than to add another new to the name. Of course it could just be a reference to Futurama!) and stem cell research (bodies grown for the purpose of infection in order to find cures). The morality of the latter being questioned in the story.

This story is also memorable for Cassandra possessing Rose. Finally Rose is sexy! Billie Piper's performance in this story (playing Cassandra possesing her body) reminds me of Billie Piper's post Who job 'Secret Diary of a Call Girl'. Also there's the further nod to cosmetic plastic surgery being taken too far. I like how it's resolved at the end with Cassandra (in Chip's body) telling her past self (ie when she was more than just a fold of skin and and a face) how beautiful she is. This was revealed earlier in the episode to be the last time that anyone told her she was beautiful. Very fitting, the last time she was told she was beautiful was when she was completely or fairly natural. Funny thing is it's  Cassandra herself that tells her that she is beautiful! Hmm self fulfilling?!

Doctor Who Project - "The Christmas Invasion"

Ooooh the first Christmas special of the new era (probably one of the better ones too) and David Tennant's first episode as The Doctor (the last minute of "The Parting of the Ways" doesn't count) although he's not around for large chunks of it. That's right it's more of the extended Tyler family drama. Woo.

"The Christmas Invasion" isn't too bad too be honest, it's camp and it ticks off all the required Christmas elements: turkey, brass band, Father Christmas, the Queen's speech (or at least a nod to it with Harriet Jones, Prime Minister advising it's been cancelled) and even snow albeit ash from the destroyed spaceship.

For me this episode has more in common with Castrovolva than any of the Christopher Eccleston episodes. Saying that I always found The 10th Doctor to be more like the 5th Doctor than any other. No surprise they teamed them up for the "Time Crash" special. Getting ahead of myself though.

All in all not a bad episode, not the worst but certainly not the best. It was a bit Torchwood though with all this blood control and threatening to kill a third of the world's population. Maybe Russell T Davies is subtly introducing us to it? After all Harriet Jones mentions knowing of Torchwood, the destruction of the Sycorax ship is done in a very Torchwood-esque fashion and in 2 episodes time we get to see the Torchwood Estate. Anyway more of that to come.

One thing I noticed on re-watching this episode is that David Tennant is credited as'The Doctor' in the closing titles whereas Christopher Eccleston was always 'Doctor Who', that's something that's bugged me upon re-watching these episodes.

Oh well onward and upward, so many classic 10th Doctor stories (and quite a few duds too!).

ALONS-Y!

Doctor Who Project - "Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways"

And here we go the first series finale in the new series era and the team find themselves waking up in futuristic versions of current TV programmes: The Doctor in Big Brother, Rose in The Weakest Link and Jack in What Not to Wear only something's different  (aside from the robot programme hosts), these are TV shows where the winner gets to live!

There's also something else that's familiar, the Gamestation itself. We've seen it before and The Doctor knows he's been there before it's Satellite 5.

The Doctor escapes the Big Brother House with his fellow housemate Lynda with a Y (aka Tanya with a Y from Eastenders) whereas Jack escapes his programme by using a well hidden mini gun - not going to guess exactly where it was hidden. Rose however isn't so lucky and gets shot by the Anne-droid after losing out in the final of The Weakest Link. However as we find out later Rose isn't dead, she's merely been transported (What confuses me about this is how the Anne-droid manages to clearly destroy the Daleks later on and not transport them?) to the Dalek mothership.

Saving Rose by landing the TARDIS around her he then sends her back to 2005 whilst he and Jack work on a bomb that will destroy everything living within the area. Not content with being left out of proceedings Rose tries her best to think of a way to return, figures out that Bad Wolf is a clue and decides that staring into the heart of the TARDIS would  be a good idea. Hang on a min didn't the last person to try this revert back to being an egg?! Far from turning Rose into a 5ft egg the TARDIS gives Rose super powers complete with glowing eyes kinda like how Jean Grey turns into the Phoenix in X-Men. Rose aka The Phoenix then goes onto destroy the Dalek empire and save the day but of course people shouldn't look into the heart of the TARDIS and it's killing her. The Doctor being the guy he is absorbs all the energy from Rose, being a Time Lord won't save him from death though but of course The Doctor has a little trick up his sleeve regeneration and it's the first regeneration of the new series. This also means the end of the 9th Doctor which is a shame because I love Eccleston's Doctor and I feel given another series or 2 he would be just as loved as Tennant, Baker, Davison et al. In his own words  he was 'fantastic'.

This series finale will mostly be remembered for the 9th-10th regeneration (as well as being the first series finale of the New Who era) but it can also be remembered for being a half decent series finale too. Unlike the series finales to come it's not a big sprawling epic that has to be bigger and better than the previous one (although to be fair there is no previous series finale in the new era) and that's why I like these 2 episodes. Fantastic!

Doctor Who Project - "Boom Town"

Continuing the hit and miss theme for this series we've had a great episode so therefore we must follow it with dross. And dross we get with the return of the Slitheen. Really RTD do we really need to see Slitheens again?! Ok we only get one survivor from 'World War Three' in the form of Blon but it's enough.

The TARDIS crew find themselves in Cardiff (again, this time in modern day) in need of a quick fuel stop using the rift (that we last saw in The 'Unquiet Dead') to charge the TARDIS. Hmm Cardiff, rift, Captain Jack I smell a spinoff. Whilst they're in town Rose invites Mickey to come join them and it's when they're all together that they spot a familiar face on the front of the Western Mail (also familiar to me having spent my university years in Wales), good old Blon Slitheen, the new mayor of Cardiff.

This episode is pretty much filler but does serve an important purpose in the overall series story arc. Firstly it flags up the words Bad Wolf for all that had missed them in earlier episodes with The Doctor saying he's heard those words before and that they've been following him. Secondly we see the heart of the TARDIS.

Long story short, not a fan of this episode but it is better than the last time we saw the Slitheen and best of all RTD kills them off as Blon reverts back to being an egg after staring into the heart of the TARDIS meaning that she'll get the chance to re-live her life and hopefully grow up to be a better person well a better Raxacoricofallapatorian at least.

And it's whilst dropping off the newly re-born egg at Raxacoricofallapatorius that The Doctor, Rose and Captain Jack find themselves in a familiar place.....

Doctor Who Project - "The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances"

Been a few weeks since I last caught up with some Eccleston Who and then I watch 4 episodes at once. As such these reviews are going to come like buses ie 3 at a time!

Just like 'Dalek' these are one of the standout stories of the series and demonstrates just how good Doctor Who could be in the right hands. In fact re-watching the series like this series 1 could potentially be the best series since it's return, well in RTD's era anyway. It's funny I should mention RTD (Russell T Davies) as it's his successor as series runner Steven Moffat that is the writer of this cracking 2 parter. It's also the first 2 parter since the disappointing 'Aliens of London'World War Three' (featuring the God awful Slitheen), showing how it's supposed to be done.

The Empty Child starts off a frantic pace, latching onto a mauve (red is camp apparently) distress signal The Doctor and Rose find themselves in wartime London 1941 during an air raid. Rose immediately gets swept up by an air balloon whilst The Doctor asks if anyone has heard a big bang recently (to laughter) before the air raid sirens start to blare. Like I said frantic start!

The story then shifts pace with The Doctor stumbling across the heart of the story the 'empty child', a creepy little boy in a gas mask asking everyone he meets "are you my mummy?". The 'empty child' seems to be stalking a young lady named Nancy who seems to be World War 2's answer to Robin Hood, robbing food from those who have aplenty to feed the young homeless orphans of London. Why is it that she won't let the strange little gas masked in whilst other children (including a new member to the party as we're advised) are free to enjoy the food? Well the answer according to Nancy is that this isn't a normal little boy, he's empty.

In the meantime Rose bumps into an exciting new swashbuckling action hero Captain Jack Harkness. Wonder if we'll see him again? ;)

Captain Jack appears to be an antithesis of The Doctor, a character who is happy to solve problems with guns and flashy technology. Rose seems suitably impressed at least, then again he did save her life then flirted within an inch of his life with her. Jack also reveals that the ship they followed was sent by him to lure the Time Agency so he could blackmail them and that it is to be destroyed by a German bomb in several hours.

The Doctor in the meantime is introduced to the err Doctor. The Doctor in this case is Victor Meldrew/Merlin's mentor who shows The Doctor his patients who all have the same curious symptoms (the same as the eponymous 'Empty Child'). Victor Meldew then develops a gas mask for a face and asks The Doctor is he is mummy. Rose and Jack enter shortly before all the patients come to life and advance on our heroes. What a cliffhanger!

 The time travelling trio escape after The Doctor gives them all a stern telling off, telling them to go to their room! The rest of the episode follows on with more fast paced action with the team running from the 'Empty Child'. After escaping they are lead by Captain Jack to the crash site. The ship that Captain Jack used to lure The Doctor and Rose is an ambulance full of the nanogenes used earlier to heal Rose's rope burnt hands. Also at the crash site we find Nancy and it is revealed that the 'Empty Child' is her little brother Jamie (great name by the way). The Doctor knows this isn't quite true though, Jamie is Nancy's son. She is the mummy that he's searching for. Here lies the answer and solution to the story. The Doctor gets Nancy to reunite with Jamie and confirm that she is his mummy, the nanogenes reconfigure his DNA rewriting the gas masked DNA and replacing it with the accurate superior DNA saving Jamie and all his victims. As The Doctor says "just this once, everybody lives".

In fact everyone does live, as Captain Jack is saved from certain death trying to dispose of the bomb and welcomed aboard

This episode has everything you required of a classic Doctor Who episode: a creepy monster, action, running, plenty of running, a twist, references to previous stories (psychic paper was first seen in the 2nd Doctor's era) and of course great writing. Upon re-watching these episodes I think that they are better than 'Dalek' and the best in the series in fact one of the best stories since the return of Doctor Who in 2005. Steven Moffat will repeat this in other New Who classics 'The Girl in the Fire Place', 'Blink' and 'Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead' before succeeding Russell T Davies as head writer. I just hope that when he relinquishes his control of the show that he still writes the occasional episode as most of the best New Who stories have come from his pen.

In Moffat we trust.

Doctor Who Project "Father's Day"

Episode 8 'Father's Day' sees Rose asking The Doctor if they can travel back to 1987 to see her Dad in his final moments. With a nod back to the 1st episode 'Rose' The Doctor suggests it's funny that she turned him down when he advised they can travel anywhere in the universe but the second he says he can travel in time she's onboard and to be careful what you wish for.

We arrive in 1987, witness Pete Tyler's death then Rose asks The Doctor if they can try again. Stupidly The Doctor agrees and this time Rose runs out to save her Dad's life changing time and creating a paradox.

Being a massive Back to the Future fan I couldn't help but draw parallels between this episode and the greatest film franchise known to man. Firstly a man who should have been run down by a car is saved, secondly time is changed OK in BTTF an alternative reality is created with Biff running Hill Valley as opposed to time eating bats.

This episode is all about families which is a bit of familiar theme with Russell T Davies' Doctor Who output. Once again it isn't The Doctor that saves the day but a regular person (OK someone who shouldn't be alive anyway) although The Doctor does sacrifice himself before Pete does. Following Pete's sacrifice order is restored including the return of The Doctor. Rose gets to say her goodbyes to the father she never knew (well not until a few hours earlier) and in doing so does subtly changes the past as Jackie tells a young Rose that Pete was run down by a young man who waited with them until the Police arrived (not a hit and run driver) along with an unknown girl who waited by Pete's side until he died.

This episode was OK, better than the last but not the best in the series. Next up the Stephen Moffat written 2 parter 'The Empty Child'/'The Doctor Dances'. Possibly the best 2 episodes of the series (and one of the few 2 parters in the RTD era that doesn't start off promising then fails to deliver in the 2nd half).

Doctor Who Project - "The Long Game"

Following on from the excellent 'Dalek', 'The Long Game' sees new 'Adam joining the TARDIS crew and travelling with The Doctor and Rose to the year 200,000. Here we find the happy time travellers aboard Satellite 5, a space station that broadcasts or more accurately manipulates the news (RTD's spin on manufacturing consent?) and The Doctor knows something's wrong. Turns out humanity is being shaped (via the news broadcasted) by The Mighty Jagrafess of the Holy Hadrojassic Maxarodenfoe (Yes I did Google it!) and The Editor from Floor 500 and has setback mankind's progress 90 years.

This episode is one of the hit and miss episodes in series 1 and is basically just a setup for the later episode 'Bad Wolf'. It's a bit of a filler, not the worst episode but far from the best. The one thing I love about it is how it demonstrates human greed and how a choice in companion can go so drastically wrong. Adam sees the wealth of information available to him in the future and decides it would be a great idea to send this information home via Rose's mobile and an answering machine in 2005. And of course he does this by getting an implant installed despite The Doctor advising him that it's outdated technology that doesn't exist in this time. Of course this comes back to bit him in the arse with information on The Doctor and Rose's identity being extracted from Adam's implant. What's interesting about this episode is the fact that it's not The Doctor who saves the day but a normal person. Even more interesting is that it's done via the same device that got them into the predicament (ie the implant).

With the day saved The Doctor drops off Adam back at his Mum's house (maybe the TARDIS isn't big enough for 2 Mancunians?) leaving him with a stern telling off and an embarrassing secret exposed with a click of the fingers.